Judges
1: The National Training Award Judge: Role specification
1.1 Overview:
National Training Awards (NTA)
National Training Awards celebrate and share excellence in practice. Identifying how employers, providers, partnerships and individuals have applied learning and development in order to create impact and achieve success. Winners will share practice and inspire others to invest in learning and development as a route to being world class.
The Strategic Aims of NTA are:
- To promote the development of skills as a key lever for the UK and global economy
- To raise standards and improve organisational and individual performance and productivity
- To improve leadership understanding and skills to utilise the transformational potential of learning
- To celebrate excellence in practice and use this to inspire others
- To recognise and promote learning and development that is demand-led and meeting the needs of the business, employers and individuals.
1.2 Core Description of the Judges Role
National Training Awards are awarded via a rigorous and fair assessment and judging process. Through judgment and debate, judging panels are able to identify award winners as well as offer detailed feedback to entrants. The Judges are separated into regional judging panels and judge entries from within their geographical area.
Each individual Judge is required to read, analyse and score the entries allocated to them, the entries are judged against the NTA category scoring criteria. Then as part of the regional panels Judges are also required to debate the entries, conduct onsite visits, judge the winners and offer feedback on the entry. UK Skills value this voluntary role and endeavour to provide the support and reward at all stages of the process.
The overall aim of the NTA Judge is to apply their experience and knowledge, and work alongside other members of the panel to judge entries and make Awards both regionally and across the UK. Once appointed NTA Judges are invited to remain on a judging panel for up to two years.
1.3 The specific responsibilities of the Judge are:
- to ensure up to date knowledge of NTA through attendance at the NTA briefing meetings and reference to the Judges handbook
- to commit to the confidentiality requirements of UK Skills
- to receive, read and analyse a maximum of 25 entries
- to fully understand the NTA category criteria and use this with the scoring system for the entry
- to review scores and ensure a personal consistency in this stage of the process
- to ensure that scores are returned in accordance with the agreed timeline
- attendance and participation at the 2 Regional panel meetings
- to synthesise the information within an entry so as to engage in the debate at panels
- to undertake a least 2 on-site visits for those entries being considered for an Award
- if selected as the Lead Judge for the visit then to set up the visit and complete the on-site visit form again in accordance with the agreed timeline. (please note that for the first visit new Judges will be supported in this process)
- to offer feedback for entrants through the panel debate and discussion process
2: The person specification
2.1 Skills & abilities:
- the ability to apply good analytical skills
- the ability to apply judging criteria
- the ability to review personal scores and achieve consistency
- organisational skills
- listening skills
- questioning skills
- reviewing and reporting skills
- be able to synthesise information as presented from a range of sources
- the ability to offer constructive comments and ideas for the debate
- the ability to develop and deliver constructive feedback
2.2 Knowledge & experience:
- having worked at a strategic/operational level within an organisation
- a good knowledge of what organisational and individual benefits look like
- knowledge and experience of an education and/or training sector
- knowledge and experience of training and development practice
- previous experience of using criterion referenced judging processes
2.3 Character & personal qualities:
- dependability & reliability
- good personal organisation
- ability to work with other members of the panel
- can manage expectations
- ability to work as part of a team
- willing to listen to the debate and achieve consensus
- have a sense of fairness
If you would like to apply to become a Judge, please callJoe O'Malley on 020 7429 2807 or email Joe.OMalley@ukskills.org.uk




